For info on my upcoming tour, including “Bob Dylan in Greenwich Village” shows in Bethlehem PA and State College, as well as gigs in Philly, Pittsburgh, Marietta OH, and Cleveland, go to https://elijahwald.com/concertdates.html
This is one of those songs that was very much of its time and unfortunately remains very current. It was one of Dylan’s earliest published compositions, appearing in Broadside magazine in 1963. Broadside was edited by Agnes “Sis” Cunningham, who had been in the Almanac Singers with Pete Seeger and Woody Guthrie, along with her husband, Gordon Friesen, and was specifically an outlet for leftist topical songs. It was integral to Dylan’s early songwriting, because it provided a way for him to get his songs published and available to other singers, and his focus on political lyrics in this period was undoubtedly influenced by the fact that the magazine would publish them.
Dylan’s political focus was also strongly influenced by his girlfriend, Suze Rotolo, who came from a committed leftist family and was working with Bayard Rustin in the New York office of CORE, the Congress of Racial Equality, and also doubled as stage manager for a Greenwich Village production of songs by Bertolt Brecht. I knew Suze, thanks to a couple of evenings together at Dave Van Ronk’s place and a few other meetings over the years, and she was a foundational figure in the Dylan story — he made his first mark as a musical conscience and spokesman for a generation of young activists, and his political outlook came directly from Suze. (There were plenty of other leftists on the scene, including Van Ronk and Pete Seeger — but I’m convinced she was his most important influence.) Suze was also a distinctive illustrator, designing the Folk City calendars and providing pictures to go along with Dylan’s songs, including the Broadside “Masters of War.”
The melody for this song comes from “Nottamun Town,” which I’ve posted about earlier. Apparently an English mummers’ song, it disappeared in Britain but survived in the United States — my earlier post includes a broadsheet version from the early 20th century — and was brought into the folk revival by Jean Ritchie. I first heard it from
Ritchie’s recording, but Dylan’s version comes from an adaptation by Boston’s reigning male folksinger, Jackie Washington. Jack — now known Jack Landron — explains that he liked Ritchie’s version, but she sang it with minor thirds while playing major chords and he wasn’t comfortable with that approach, so put it in a minor key, and Dylan followed his model. He says Ritchie’s husband called him and suggested they sue Dylan for a share of the royalties and he declined; other sources say Dylan eventually paid Ritchie a lump sum.
Be that as it may, it is one of Dylan’s most powerful political songs. My version simplifies the chords even more — basically staying on one chord all the way through — and I typically sing a mix of his verses; I rarely remember all of them, and some feel more powerful to me on some days, others on others.
The performance in my video was filmed at Club Passim in Cambridge and includes a spoken portion, because I’ve found that a lot of people nod along to political songs without necessarily giving them much thought, and if you want to actually make a statement, you need to make a statement. This performance was shortly after I had spent a night in jail for protesting the Israeli assault on Gaza, so that was foremost in my mind; if I made the same statement today, I would include some other major arms-dealing countries: the US is far and away the largest, with over 40% of the global market, followed by France with around 10%, then Russia, Germany, China, Italy, Israel, and the UK. Which is to say the “civilized world” is overwhelmingly responsible for filling the world with murderous technology, and the capitalist system is largely financed by that market. It is not a new story, but grows more devastating and disgusting by the year, and I don’t expect songs to change that, but if all you can do is protest… you protest.