Stackolee (Professor Longhair)

For info on my upcoming tour, hitting Bethlehem PA, Philly, State College, Pittsburgh, Marietta OH, and Cleveland, go to https://elijahwald.com/concertdates.html

The most protean of American ballad themes, the story of Stack Lee Shelton’s killing of Billy Lyons in a St. Louis bar on Christmas in 1892 has spawned such a diverse range of songs that I play three versions — this one, John Hurt’s “Stagolee,” and Furry Lewis’s “Stackolee” — and they that don’t have a single verse in common. (I’ll admit that the “please don’t take my life” verse in this version is a close cousin to the similar one in Hurt’s version, but the denouement is handled with nastier relish here.)

I got this version from Professor Longhair, the dean of New Orleans R&B pianists and a superlatively wild singer — I’ve previously posted about him with my version of his “Hey Now, Baby” — and it was a local standard, first recorded by a pianist named Archibald in 1950 and later turned into a #1 hit by Lloyd Price.

I don’t know who originated this version or how it evolved, but there is an intriguing local back story. Alan Lomax transcribed several versions of the Stack Lee ballad in New Orleans in 1935, and one of the longest and most discursive came from a barroom pianist named Sullivan Rock. Lomax wrote about following Rock from one bar to another, then to some private homes, transcribing verse after verse, and his handwritten notes include several other songs he likewise credited to Rock. I tell the whole story, with Lomax’s romantic recollections and some further musings, in Jelly Roll Blues.

Sullivan Rock never recorded, and aside from Lomax’s notes, there would be no trace of him, aside from a couple of listings in the New Orleans city directory… except that forty years later Professor Longhair gave an interview in which he named Rock as one of his early influences, saying, “Sullivan Rock was my main person because he had the spirit and soul.”

Longhair’s version of the Stack Lee ballad doesn’t share any verses with the one Lomax collected from Rock, and there’s no way to tell how the song traveled and mutated over the decades, but in any case it became a New Orleans standard, to the point that a lot of people think it came from there. Along the way, the name of the man Stack shot mutated from the prosaic Billy Lyons to the evocative Billy the Lion — historically inaccurate, but clearly a better ballad name.

As for me, I fell in love with Longhair’s playing back in the 1980s, though I stupidly didn’t get to New Orleans in time to see him live, and worked up a few of his songs for guitar, trying to preserve some of the flavor of his rumba-boogie rhythms, then added some harmonica… and came out with this.

5 thoughts on “Stackolee (Professor Longhair)”

  1. Hey Elijah , speaking of Cousins , me , Sandrine’s Cousin , Mark Polinsky was born in St . Louis, MO. I always liked this song. Sandrine’s Uncle Bob , went to St. Louis University Medical School and would often stop by our house when I was just a young boy. Keep Up The Great Work ! Peace & Love to you both, Cuz’.

  2. Hello Mr. Wald,
    Do you take song suggestions?
    How about “Dyin’ Crapshooter’s Blues” which I’ve learned has been done by Blind Willie McTell.
    I also found this link: https://earlyblues.org/essays-tracing-the-origins-of-dying-crapshooters-blues-chapter-one/. It’s an exhausting essay that I couldn’t finish reading, but you may find some parts of it valuable.

    I enjoy your music and am subscribed to emails of your new YouTube releases. I also just started reading your book about the alternative history of American popular music. It’s much more accessible reading than the essay I linked you to!

    Thanks for all your enjoyable music and history.

  3. I was lucky enough to see Fess live, and one of the few people who eclipsed his performance was James Booker at the Maple Leaf.

  4. I like “Dying Crapshooter’s Blues,” but this blog is specifically of songs I know by memory, and I never learned that one — I’ve backed people who sang it, but never sang it myself. I have posted “St. James Infirmary,” which is somewhat related…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.