Story of a Scam
by Elijah Wald

My 84-year-old relative has been scammed out of more than $25 thousand dollars. Here is the story:

A group called VIDOL, Veterans in Defense of Liberty, sent my relative an announcement that she had reached the fourth stage to win a sweepstakes for one million dollars.

She sent back the coupon, with a note saying she only needed $500,000 -- which is obviously silly, but she was trying to be reasonable. Someone giving the name Barbara Becker called, supposedly from the law office of Becker, McKenzie and Associates. She had an associate named Winston Donovan, at the same number, who took over the project. (I am guessing that they originally understood my relative was male, and switched genders when they got a woman, but that is just a guess.)

This is a frightening and isolating time for many people. My relative is concerned about the future of Social Security, wants something to leave her children, and so on... and these scams prey on those insecurities.

O
ver the next conversations, "Winston"explained their organization was involved with a charity and needed her to send money to help two students in the Philippines. She tried to send $800 by Western Union to someone named Ramil Ellis Bernardo, which was not received and got cancelled. A week later she sent a MoneyGram for $700 to Nico Jones Benito. Four days later she tried again to send $800 by Western Union to Benito, but gave the wrong address, so sent it by MoneyGram. (Total scam expenditure $1,500.)

Meanwhile, they got her two buy three Vanilla cards at Walgreen’s: on Aug 10 for $500, which was eventually used at Nordstrom Rack in Iowa; on Aug 11 for $300, which was used to buy stuff at RiteAid online; on Aug 14, for $500, which has not yet been used, and we hope to get money back. (Another $800)

Then they said she would have to pay taxes on her winnings, and for some reason needed to pay some of the tax in advance, and for some reason it had to be in cash... she does not remember all the details, but they provided her with a number for the Federal Gaming Commission, so she could check them out. She does not remember if she ever called that number, but one way or another she ended up mailing over $4,000 in cash to an address in Harvey, Louisiana, by UPS overnight, on 4 Aug. After that, over the course of a month they persuaded her to send three further payments, all to the same address.

(Total scam: close to $28,000.)

They explained that when this was all finished an attorney named Mabel Gray would fly to Boston from Buffalo, via JetBlue, arriving at 8:23am, and bring her a million five hundred thousand dollars -- they had persuaded her, over the course of their conversations, to accept not only the million, but an additional half million.

Then, fortunately, we learned about what was happening. We reported it to the police, who contacted the couple whose address in Harvey was on the packages of cash. They apparently knew nothing about this, and the detective says that is typical: that someone just follows the UPS truck and takes the package out of the mailbox when it arrives. True? Maybe. In any case, the local police in Harvey had no record for the couple.

Winston Donovan called at 8:30 on Monday morning, 7 Sept. I answered and when I said my relative was asleep and tried to ask him something, he hung up.

Meanwhile I had called both the Becker, McKenzie office number and the Federal Gaming Commission number. It was the long weekend and both got voice mails, the first with options to click through to various attorneys or a receptionist, the latter answered as Federal Trade Commission, with options to click through to report fraud or get informational booklets.

Tuesday morning, I called again. A temp at Becker, McKenzie said Winston Donovan and Barbara Becker were in a meeting, but would call me when they got out. The detective called as well, and was told the same. Within an hour, the number had been disconnected -- and there was no longer any answer at the "Federal Trade Commision."

There is a Becker, McKenzie law office in Dallas, TX, which I called, and they say they have been getting dozens of calls about scams using their name, though the others seem to have mostly been fake loan agencies.

My relative has lost her immediately accessible savings, with no serious hope of getting any of it back or learning the real identities of the scammers. I am posting this because there are no internet hits suggesting the danger of responding to the Vidol National Sweepstakes, despite them presumably having sent out thousands of mailers, nor for the various names we were given... which are undoubtedly false, but may have been given to other people who are still caught in the same web.